Through three weeks of the NFL season, we’ve already seen our fair share of surprises—from the Indianapolis Colts being undefeated, to the Kansas City Chiefs being just 1-2. Equally, the 2025 Offensive Rookie of the Year odds are surprising to this point as well. Some players have seen sizable changes to their 2025 Offensive Rookie of the Year odds.
Ashton Jeanty
It’s been a slow start for Pete Carroll in his new home as the head coach of the Las Vegas Raiders. They’re averaging just 17.7 points per game, 26th in the NFL. Much of it is due to their blocking, or lack thereof. According to ESPN, Jeanty has rushed for 144 yards, with 145 yards gained after contact. (This is so bad it’s almost hard to wrap your head around.)
This Ashton Jeanty stat is wild 🤯 pic.twitter.com/8LioF38C76
— ESPN Fantasy Sports (@ESPNFantasy) September 23, 2025
Before the start of the season, Jeanty was at +250 odds. Now, Jeanty’s 2025 Offensive Rookie of the Year odds sit at +1000 on FanDuel. Jeanty could still break out down the stretch, but the Raiders will have to do some serious soul searching along their offensive line if that’s going to be a possibility.
Travis Hunter
Jacksonville Jaguars head coach Liam Coen is still searching for the most impactful way to use the talented Travis Hunter week to week. So far, that looks to be on the defensive side of the ball. As a result, his odds for the Offensive Rookie of the Year have gotten considerably worse. From the +1000 odds prior to Week 1, Hunter now sits at +4000 at DraftKings. At least with Jeanty, he’s getting the volume necessary to make a run at the award, but if Coen keeps this up with Hunter’s usage, he won’t finish with the same opportunities as other players on this list.
Cam Skattebo
Anyone who watched running back Cam Skattebo at Arizona State knows what a tough player he is. He almost willed the Sun Devils past the Texas Longhorns in the College Football Playoff quarterfinals. The Giants took a chance on him in the fourth round in this past draft, and he was +5000 on the 2025 Offensive Rookie of the Year odds board. Giants lead running back Tyrone Tracy Jr. was injured in Week 3 against the Kansas City Chiefs, and Skattebo took advantage of the boost in usage, going for over 100 yards from scrimmage while scoring a touchdown. As a result, his odds have shifted dramatically to +2000.
Tyler Warren
It came as a big surprise when the Chicago Bears drafted tight end Colston Loveland over Tyler Warren, who many scouts drooled over in the draft process. As a result, the Indianapolis Colts selected Warren with the 14th pick, and he has been instrumental in the Colts’ early-season success.
In his debut, he saw nine targets and brought in seven of them for 76 yards. The following week, he saw seven targets, catching four for 79 yards. If the Colts are to remain contenders for a playoff spot as the AFC South frontrunner, Warren would likely be a significant factor. He opened at +3500 right after the draft, but is just +550 among the 2025 Offensive Rookie of the Year odds going into Week 4.
Emeka Egbuka
Tampa Bay Buccaneers wide receiver Emeka Egbuka has been one of the most fun rookies to watch through the first three weeks. While he didn’t haul in a touchdown against the New York Jets, he still had multiple highlight-reel plays in which he displayed his talent. His opening odds moved from +3000 to +2400 when it became clear that Chris Godwin would miss more time than initially thought.
While Godwin is preparing to return, reports claim that Mike Evans will miss three to four weeks. While there may end up being a lot of mouths to feed on this Bucs offense, Egbuka has displayed his talent, and there’s no reason the Bucs will look to go away from him anytime soon. He is currently the favorite at +350 on FanDuel.
Jaxson Dart
Of all the movers, New York Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart is perhaps the most shocking. Following a poor performance by Russell Wilson on Sunday Night Football, the Giants announced they would start implementing a plan to make Dart the starting quarterback moving forward. As a result, his odds shifted dramatically from +3000 before Week 3 all the way down to +650, despite never throwing a pass in his pro career.